patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices
Unknown

Who is Responsible for Improving the Public Schools in South Cobb?

As I research and study the many wonderfully amazing public schools in this school district, CCSD,  I can't help but notice that all schools are not created equal.  By that I mean that some of the schools appear to be struggling with reaching higher levels of achievement.  Unfortunately, many of those schools are in South Cobb.

I often ask myself, "Is this acceptable for my child/our children and community?"  My answer is a resounding NO.  There will be those people that will agree with this perspective and those whom will, of course, disagree.  However, one can not disavow the data; it speaks for itself.  I have heard many opinions why this achievement gap exists from lack of parent involvement to less than stellar teachers to weak leadership at the school and district levels.

Having communicated with students, parents, teachers, administrators, Title I representatives, area superintendents, other district leaders, and board members, I believe there is enough blame to share for why these schools are struggling (or failing).  No matter who is responsible, it is for certain the children are the victims in this cruel circle.  

I do believe there are successes and good things going on in our schools, but have we as a community set the bar too low by not demanding higher expectations of our schools? Or do we have high expectations but just don't know how to come together to help manifest them within the schools? 

Please know that my children/our children here in South Cobb deserve the same high standards and expectations as many of the other schools in the district.  Who is ultimately responsible for improving the public schools here in South Cobb?  Have the parents, educators, administrators, district leaders and school board failed the children of South Cobb? 

Let's start an honest dialogue to get underneath the problems and create real and sustainable solutions.

Patch Local Voices bloggers are members of the community who write about the issues that matter most to them. They are not paid journalists. If you have a unique viewpoint, a question or something to say, consider being a Patch Local Voices blogger. It's easy. Simply click this link and start writing.

 

 

Jessica Jones

7:36 pm on Tuesday, September 4, 2012

I agree! I truly believe that the change can start with the administration at local schools. There is so much that they can choose to do...or not do. Your would be surprised.

Reply

Jay Young

11:26 am on Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Straight to the question, I feel both the cause and solution reside with the collective lot of all the groups you mentioned in the article. Albeit I believe that the parental community is the largest stakeholder in this matter, and should shoulder much of the "blame", I believe many of the pieces which make up "the system" are unprepared to deal with the overwhelming rate at which students in the area fail to exceed the standard. I feel the former standard, currently being replaced by the new Common Core Standard, was both weak and perfunctory in it's spirit and execution. Unfortunately, it (CCS) may further compound the problem of the gap in achievement due to it's anticipated rigor. At least the proverbial bar has seemingly been raised... I just hope our kids don't get left hanging from it.

It boils down to an accountability matter. One of the biggest steps in problem solving (in this matter) is the creation of opportunities for successful, quantifiable, sustainable change. This is most difficult as people are creatures of habit and systems created by people are the worst example of that. Additionally, in a system where 2-3% is significant increase in performance, what do you do? Take it as a great accomplishment? I feel the bar slipping again already. But I digress...

As a community, there needs to be a fundamental shift in our approach to education as a whole. Hopefully this topic gets as many (or more) comments as the recent debate on citizenship! Yeah... Right!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Larry King

8:17 am on Sunday, September 9, 2012

Jay, I hope the comments can lead to some actions on the part of parents and school administrators that lead to measurable improvements beyond the 2 - 3%.

Comment_arrow

Albert

8:40 am on Sunday, September 9, 2012

Larry,
Why are we not will to jump into the fight also. It's all of our responsibility. We need to hold each other accountable to the future of our country and our kids. Unless you like giving people your tax dollars and having know say in their performance.

I'm Fired up and Ready to Go!!!!

ADT

12:17 pm on Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Many thanks to all for a much needed call to arms. My wife and I, as well as, other parents in the South Cobb community have articulated this same messaging to our local school leadership, Area Supt’s (we’ve had 3 in 4 yrs), District Title I, and the GaDoE Title I. The consistent messaging from all these leaders was "compliance".

If the schools are compliant (in terms of Title I expenditures, quantity of “highly qualified” teachers, and the minimum of 1% spent on Parental Involvement) then they have done all they are supposed to. Never mind, that the children are 2 grades behind in reading and math with “highly qualified" teachers, or that the culture within the 4 walls of the schools are so toxic you run out of breath trying to escape the ignorance and visible lack of value for our children and their parents. Don’t get me wrong, there are a few good teachers but not enough to make a sizeable difference.
I thank the Lord we were able to successfully exercise School Choice thru HB 251 and remove our child from the Title I “brand” to give her an uninhibited opportunity to explore the true value of a “student-centric” educational environment. Don’t be confused, my child was a Target student, and achieved your typical above average academic buzz in a Title I school. But was she really competitive? Could she really compete with students on a global scale? Our children are being held hostage by a demoralizing system that we call “Title I”.

Reply

Claudette Clarke

12:38 pm on Wednesday, September 5, 2012

I have a coworker that lives in East Cobb and I hear about the differences in educational opportunities. But we also have a lot of underutilized resources here in South Cobb. I see it every year at Career Day at my local elementary. The parents and community members have a wealth of knowledge that can support our teachers. We can help with good citizenship, arts, computer literacy, business ownership, etc.

Reply
Comment_arrow

ADT

1:09 pm on Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Yes we can ! No political slogan intended - but the school leadership in South Cobb has to openly accept support offered by the parents and community. The only involvment they seek is to come help set up for Fall Festival or Christmas with Santa or maybe do some stapling, cutting, and Chik-Fil-A biscuit fundraising, but please don't ask to be engaged further than that. Many Title I Schools don't even have a Room Mom's program, in fact, some don't want the parents to participate even as chaperones on trips to the zoo with the K-2 children. It's toxic - oh and Career Day, that's unheard of at a Title I school. I actually brought it up as an idea myself during a local council school meeting to drive more value based parental engagemement, it went as far as this blog. So not to beat a dead horse in the ground but South Cobb requires a Title I overhaul from the ground up. We need to attract better leaders, teachers and pay them appropriately to remain and drive sustainable results. This climate is infectious as any child who experiences this believes it is normal because they know nothing else. Parents lets step up and take our schools and communities back !!

Claudette Clarke

2:37 pm on Wednesday, September 5, 2012

I agree with you that we all need to step it up and stop focusing on the superficial. One correction though is that the Career Day is at a Title I school.

Reply

Valerie Testman

4:00 pm on Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Mr. Young, I too agree that parents are the real accountability backstop for the educational system. But, I don't collectiovely hear their voices on any issues here in South Cobb.

Ms. Jones, I know administrators have power and control over so much within their schools, but you are right, they may not always choose to use it wisely for the benefit of serving the children with whom they have been charged with educating.
We must demand excellence, and be prepared to give it as well. The schools in South Cobb have been overlooked for far too long by the system.

ADT, Title I overhaul?? Now that may be an idea. Afterall, most if not all the schools in South Cobb are Title I. There is a commitee the CCSD can create, "Title I Improvement Committee" because I am so over the "Calendar Committee".
By the way, I think there needs to be more education on what it means to be a Title I school and how much money comes to the CCSD annually to help improve Title I schools.

Reply

Larry King

8:10 pm on Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Change is difficult and can be painfull. So I guess the easier path is more dialouge. If we continue to do what we have always done, how can we expect change?

Reply

Monica DeLancy

3:42 pm on Friday, September 7, 2012

Parents are involved in the South Cobb area, also the community is involved. I agree that educating are children is a partnership. If you are interested in attending a parent leadership brunch hosted by we thrive on the drive please contact me at monica@wethriveonthedrive.com. At the brunch our School Board Representative David Morgan will deliver greetings and State Representative will give updates from legislation. Ms. Kiddada Grey will do a presentation on parental involvement. The brunch is scheduled on September 15, 2012 10 am-12pm. Please email me if you would like to attend. The time is now to be proactive, and not reactive we get one shot with educating our children.

Reply

L A Hays

8:29 am on Saturday, September 8, 2012

How about recruiting South Cobb seniors (like me) who want to be involved in their community? David Morgan, would you give a presentation at the new senior center on Powder Springs Road or at Freeman Poole to give our seniors some specific information on how we can get involved? Cobb County Senior Services, where are you on this opportunity?

Or are you unemployed? Use some of that time to network through the school system by volunteering.

Less talk, more walk.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Monica DeLancy

3:08 pm on Sunday, September 9, 2012

Correction State Representative Alisha T. Morgan will be present at Parent Leadership brunch hosted by We Thrive On The Drive.com. Senior citizens are invited please contact me at monica@wethriveonthedrive.com if you would like to attend.

Albert

3:54 pm on Saturday, September 8, 2012

We have a lot of talkers and No Walkers... Let's support the empowerment of the parents and the communities independent involvement in our communities schools.

We have a lot of runners and no one willing to take a stand. Focus on what's right for the kids and the community. Not on what's easy or expedient.

See you at Mableton Rocks!!! We got to raise money for the mission to take back our community and take responsibilty for it's success. Who are we waiting on? Hopefully not the Government or East Cobb.

Reply

Albert

4:01 pm on Saturday, September 8, 2012

Oh!!! Yeah.. See you at the Parent Involvement Brunch. Hosted by Monica DeLancy. It for the whole community not just Parents. If you don't have kids in school, understand that your propert value is effected by the success of the schools in our area. You have a stake in the school systems success.

Reply

Andrea Young

1:03 am on Sunday, September 9, 2012

I'm not sure what your definition of an involved parent is but, I am yet to see a good turnout for school functions that do not involve a child singing or dancing. And
yes .... everyone wants to see their child on stage but, I would like to see more support and praise for good no outstanding academics. For so long we have just been satisfied and working with what we have, not wanting to step on toes or hurt feelings. The bar is set very low for children in this area and if the schools in South Cobb are doing the best they can, then their best is not good enough for my children.

Reply

Jay Young

3:07 pm on Monday, September 10, 2012

Related to this topic is what's going on in Chicago. The whole country is watching this! CNN has reported:

"The primary disagreement appears to be teacher job security after a new evaluation program based on standardized test scores. Chicago Teachers Union board member Jay Rehak called the idea "data-driven madness."
As many as 6,000 teachers could lose their jobs under the evaluation system, according to Lewis, who called the system "unacceptable."

"This is no way to measure the effectiveness of an educator," she said Sunday. "Further, there are too many factors beyond our control which impact how well some students perform on standardized tests such as poverty, exposure to violence, homelessness, hunger and other social issues beyond our control."

There's NO WAY to measure the effectiveness of an educator?! From the Teacher's Union board member?! Significant tax revenue is spent on data systems and she's essentially disregarding it's effectiveness. Once again, transiency, hunger and poverty are the culprits. What a mess... Keep an eye on this.

Reply
Comment_arrow

L A Hays

8:22 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Data systems are only as good as the data fed into them and the algorithms used to process that data. Arbitrary standards set in place by politicians are the best way to generate bad data. Feed in meaningless data and you get meaningless results. It would be great if students were merely the factors of production as well as the finished products. We could ensure the quality of the raw materials before they ever hit the assembly line and measure the quality of the products in detail as they moved down the line. Flawed products would stop the entire line until each one was brought up to standard, or get tossed out to keep the production rate up. Is this really the model to use to guarantee that there's an effective system in place to educate our children? If so, then let's consider our teachers as the line workers: They have no control over the attainment of raw materials; they have no control over the design of the models they're assembling; they have no control over the management that sets the production standards; they have no control over what happens before or after their piece of the production is completed; they have no control over whatever technology they've been given to produce their products; they have little control over where assembly happens. Education isn't a factory; I don't want standardized children. We surely need to measure effectiveness of the system, but we're not there yet.

Comment_arrow

Jay Young

10:05 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

@L A Hays I understand your point fully, as well as the analogy you present - and I agree with you that isn't and shouldn't be a factory. Regarding the quality and improvement of products, there are strategies/philosophies (i.e. Six Sigma, ITIL, etc.) that seek to monitor, manage and improve products and/or service. I'm in no way suggesting either of them would work for education, as they were developed with their respective industries in mind. However, they each (along with others) suggest, with great result, that you can plan, monitor the process and make changes during the process that impact the outcome.

Regarding your statement about data systems, I couldn't agree more. The reporting from the data is what is relatively suspect many times. However, that is self applied pressure in my opinion. The whole purpose of data driven schools, the reporting from them and the multiple tiers that scrub that data (local, state and/or Fed) is/was to satisfy the NCLB requirements. I've always thought, "why take on all the stress and just turn down the Fed's money and take a more holistic approach to teaching." Again, education isn't my professional realm, so it may very well be the perspective of a prototypical outsider. Just makes since to me... However, even in that case I feel data and reporting is still needed.

Comment_arrow

Jay Young

10:13 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

@L A Hays (2) Your perspective seems to be that of someone either inside or very close to education and I am all ears since I am not (albeit I've spent a significant amount of time on School Councils working with Teachers and Admins). It's rather disappointing to hear of all of the obstacles teachers face in educating children and seems as though they collectively create quite an impasse. Serious Questions: (1) Why teach if this is the environment? Is this only Public School? Will nearing the end of NCLB make things easier?

Valerie Testman

6:35 am on Tuesday, September 11, 2012

There is a way to measure everything. These so called culprits may have an effect on some of the children's ability to learn, but is it the exception or the rule? If you are taught to value education, then you will govern yourself accordingly, inspite of how much money you have.

Reply

Leave a comment